Group variables: random and specific presentation


Group variables: random and specific presentation

Author
Message
paughl
paughl
Guru
Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 46, Visits: 154
Hi Folks,

--I have 2 versions of each stim.
--Participants should only ever get 1 of the versions of each stim.
--Participants should get 50% of Version 1 and 50% of Version 2 (ie: half the participants get the alternate version).
--AND THIS IS THE BIT I NEED HELP WITH: For all participants, the first stim they get should always be a randomly selected Version 1 stim.  This stim should not be repeated later.

Here's how I've done everything except the last point above (s=Version1, ns=Version2):

<variables>
/ group = (1 of 2) (sit1=s1, sit2=ns2, sit3=s3, sit4=ns4, sit5=s5, sit6=ns6, sit7=s7, sit8=ns8, sit9=s9, sit10=ns10,
sit11=s11, sit12=ns12, sit13=s13, sit14=ns14, sit15=s15, sit16=ns16, sit17=s17, sit18=ns18, sit19=s19, sit20=ns20)
/ group = (2 of 2) (sit1=ns1, sit2=s2, sit3=ns3, sit4=s4, sit5=ns5, sit6=s6, sit7=ns7, sit8=s8, sit9=ns9, sit10=s10,
sit11=ns11, sit12=s12, sit13=ns13, sit14=s14, sit15=ns15, sit16=s16, sit17=ns17, sit18=s18, sit19=ns19, sit20=s20)
</variables>

Many thanks in advance!

paul
Tags
Dave
Dave
Supreme Being
Supreme Being (679K reputation)Supreme Being (679K reputation)Supreme Being (679K reputation)Supreme Being (679K reputation)Supreme Being (679K reputation)Supreme Being (679K reputation)Supreme Being (679K reputation)Supreme Being (679K reputation)Supreme Being (679K reputation)

Group: Administrators
Posts: 9.8K, Visits: 46K
Impossible to answer based on the provided information. For example, it isn't at all clear what e.g. "sit1" is. Is it a <text> or <picture> element? Is it a <trial> element?  Or perhaps a <block>?

Since you do not explain at all how you select stimuli in the first place, etc., the question of how to force the selection of a certain type of stimulus cannot be answered either.

paughl
paughl
Guru
Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 46, Visits: 154
Apologies.

Attached is the full script.

Thanks,
paul
Attachments
SIT2.exp (415 views, 49.00 KB)
Dave
Dave
Supreme Being
Supreme Being (679K reputation)Supreme Being (679K reputation)Supreme Being (679K reputation)Supreme Being (679K reputation)Supreme Being (679K reputation)Supreme Being (679K reputation)Supreme Being (679K reputation)Supreme Being (679K reputation)Supreme Being (679K reputation)

Group: Administrators
Posts: 9.8K, Visits: 46K
This seems like an awkward way to set this up. There should be no reason whatsoever to have separate a separate <block>, <trial>, <video>, etc. elements for each single scenario.

At any rate, the way you designed that procedure, there is no way to force a certain type of stimulus as the 1st trial.

All you need is one ns-<block> element, one ns-<trial> element, one ns-<video> element. Same for "s". Then simply switch <item> elements via the <variables>.

In essence:
<block myblock>
/ trials = [1=uc_trial; 2-4=noreplace(uc_trial,lc_trial,lc_trial)]
</block>

<variables>
/ group = (1 of 2) (ucitems=g1uc; lcitems=g1lc)
/ group = (2 of 2) (ucitems=g2uc; lcitems=g2lc)
</variables>

<trial uc_trial>
/ stimulusframes = [1=uppercase]
/ validresponse = (57)
</trial>

<trial lc_trial>
/ stimulusframes = [1=lowercase]
/ validresponse = (57)
</trial>

<text uppercase>
/ items = ucitems
</text>

<text lowercase>
/ items = lcitems
</text>

<item g1uc>
/ 1 = "A"
/ 2 = "B"
</item>

<item g1lc>
/ 1 = "c"
/ 2 = "d"
</item>

<item g2uc>
/ 1 = "C"
/ 2 = "D"
</item>

<item g2lc>
/ 1 = "a"
/ 2 = "b"
</item>

paughl
paughl
Guru
Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 46, Visits: 154
Thanks Dave. Makes sense.
paughl
paughl
Guru
Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 46, Visits: 154
Hi Dave,

In trying to implement this suggestion, I come up with an issue:

My experiment involves this kind of sequence for every stim:

instruction  >> audio >> post audio question page (which includes multiple elements)

As the audio and the question page need to match up, how do i use your suggestion above with the item element and group variables?

Many thanks,
paul



Dave
Dave
Supreme Being
Supreme Being (679K reputation)Supreme Being (679K reputation)Supreme Being (679K reputation)Supreme Being (679K reputation)Supreme Being (679K reputation)Supreme Being (679K reputation)Supreme Being (679K reputation)Supreme Being (679K reputation)Supreme Being (679K reputation)

Group: Administrators
Posts: 9.8K, Visits: 46K
You would do this the same way as always -- the existence of <variables> doesn't matter.

For pairing items / different stimuli, see the "How to Present Stimulus Pairs" topic in the documentation.

Alternatively, you can /branch based on the stimulus item presented.

paughl
paughl
Guru
Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)Guru (6.2K reputation)

Group: Forum Members
Posts: 46, Visits: 154
thank you Dave! Smile
GO


Reading This Topic


Login
Existing Account
Email Address:


Password:


Social Logins

Select a Forum....






Millisecond Forums


Search